The final result was the Bull “Apostolicae Curae”, in which Anglican orders were declared to be invalid. As the Bull itself explains at length, its decision rests on. APOSTOLICAE CURAE. Pope Leo XIII. Apostolic letter of His Holiness by Divine Providence giving judgement on Anglican Ordinations, 13 September 1. Apostolicae curae et caritatis, qua Pastorem magnum ovium, Dominum nostrum Iesum Christum (Hebr. XIII, 20), referre pro munere et imitari, aspirante eius.
|Published (Last):||23 April 2012|
|PDF File Size:||14.65 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||19.43 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
In other words, priests are seen as pastors whose authority extends to kerygmatic, didactic, sacramental and benedictory roles. They unanimously agreed that the case proposed had already been adjudicated with full cognizance by the Apostolic See, and that the renewed investigation had only served to bring into clearer light the justice and wisdom with which the Holy See had settled the whole question.
They with one accord agreed that the question laid before them had been already adjudicated upon with full knowledge of the Apostolic See, and that this renewed discussion and examination of the issues had only served to bring apostolicwe more clearly the wisdom and accuracy with which that decision had been made.
This was based on the fact that Timothy ruled 1 Ti. MissaeCanon 3. He apostoliace summoned them to Apostolicadirected them to interchange writings, and, placing at their disposal all the documents available, directed them to further investigate and discuss it. Eastern Orthodox lines were inserted in the nineteenth century.
So it comes to pass that, as the Sacrament of Order and the true sacerdotium of Christ were utterly eliminated from the Anglican rite, and hence the sacerdotium is in no wise conferred truly and validly in the episcopal consecration of the same rite, for the like reason, therefore, the episcopate can in no wise be truly and validly conferred by it, and this the more so because among the first duties of the episcopate is that of ordaining ministers for the Holy Eucharist and sacrifice.
Socials Connect with us online. The former have been moved by an awareness of the excellence of the Christian priesthood and a desire that their ministers should not be without its twofold power concerning the body of Christ, while the latter have been prompted by the wish to remove an obstacle in the way of the Anglicans’ return to unity. Although the Church does not judge what is in the mind of the minister, she must pass judgment on what appears in the external rite.
And we, not disregarding such desires apotolicae opinions, above all, obeying the dictates of apostolic charity, have considered that nothing should be left untried that might in any way tend to preserve souls from injury or procure their advantage.
Second Lateran Council — A. In the first place, therefore, consideration was given to the chief documents by which Our Predecessors, qpostolicae the request of Queen Mary, made special provision for the reconciliation of the English Church.
It has, therefore, pleased Us to graciously permit the cause to be reexamined, so that, through the extreme care taken in the apostllicae examination, all doubt, or even shadow of doubt, should be removed for the future.
With these gestures the Catholic Church already intuits, recognises a reality.
A Critique of Apostolicae Curae
For example, in excommunicating a heretic and anathematising his purported heresy, it is generally acknowledged that it is possible for even an Ecumenical Council to err in ascribing the said heresy to the person involved, through misinterpretation or misreporting crae his words or intent.
Catholic Online School Free Catholic education for all. In the circumstances of the ordination of Matthew Parker to the episcopate, however, when a growing conflict was brewing between Queen Elizabeth and the pope, the consecrating bishops could hardly have intended to do what the Roman Catholic Church did.
For an opinion already prevalent, confirmed more than once by the action and constant practice of the Church, maintained that when in England, shortly after it was rent from the center of Christian Unity, a new rite for conferring Holy Orders was publicly introduced under Edward VI, the true Sacrament of Order as instituted by Christ lapsed, and with it the hierarchical succession.
Apostolicae curaehowever, takes no account of the preface. qpostolicae
Apostolicae Curae |
He commissioned a number of men, whose opinions on the matter were known to be divergent, to state, each, the ground of his judgment, in writing. There is, on the contrary, a nativa Ordinalis indoles ac spiritusa “natural character and spirit of the Ordinal,” that is fundamentally opposed to the Catholic doctrine. The final result was the Bull “Apostolicae Curae”, in which Anglican apostolicwe were declared to be invalid.
As far as the Roman Catholic Church is concerned, I think it needs to look carefully again at Apostolicae Curae and its status.
The exact scope of the defect of intention apstolicae the pope had in mind was the object of debate in the twentieth century among Catholic theologians who were persuaded of the invalidity of Anglican ordinations, yet disagreed as to the nature of the intention that would be required for validity.
Clement Apsotolicae issued a Decree on 17 April,that he should be ordained unconditionally, and he grounds his decision on the “defect of form and intention”.
It is crae relevant to examine here whether the episcopate be a completion of the priesthood, or an order distinct from it; or whether, when bestowed, as they say per saltumon one who is not a priest, it has or has not its effect. Neither author represented low church or evangelical views [a] and some evangelicals distanced themselves from the response. As the Bull itself explains at length, its decision rests on extrinsic and on intrinsic grounds. This practice is fully proved by the numerous cases of absolute re-ordination according to the Catholic rite even in Rome.
The Bull concludes with the usual declaration of the authority of this Apostolic letter. It was in vain that from the time of Charles I some men attempted to admit some notion of sacrifice and priesthood, and that, later on, certain additions were made to the Ordinal; and equally vain is the contention of a relatively small party among the Anglicans, formed in more recent times, that apostklicae said Ordinal can be made to bear a sound and orthodox sense.
Leo XIII Judgement on Anglican Ordinations
The introduction reviews the pope’s benevolent regard toward the people of England, the “common view” that the sacrament of Order lapsed under Edward VI because of the new rite that was then introduced, and the fact that in recent times many Anglicans have judged their orders valid because they believed in “the excellence of the Christian priesthood.
For an opinion already prevalent, confirmed more than once by the action and constant practice of the Church, maintained that when in England, shortly after it was rent from the centre of Christian Unity, a new rite for conferring Holy Orders was publicly introduced under Edward VI, the true Sacrament of Order as instituted by Christ lapsed, and with it the hierarchical succession.
Dedicated to the Immaculate Heart of Mary. The extrinsic grounds are to be found in the fact of the implicit approval of the Holy See given to the constant practice of unconditionally ordaining convert clergymen from the Anglican Church who desired to become priests, and in the explicit declarations of the Holy See as to the invalidity of Anglican orders on every occasion when its decision was evoked.