16 set. Com base nas obras A teoria da democracia revisitada – o debate contemporâneo (Giovanni Sartori), Poliarquia: Participação e Oposição. A Teoria da Democracia Revisitada – Giovani Sartori. 5 likes. Book. From a contemporary point of view, within political science, reference may be made to the work of Giovanni Sartori, A Teoria da Democracia Revisitada, trans.
|Published (Last):||21 October 2016|
|PDF File Size:||5.9 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||7.60 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
The administration made three key concessions in order to pass the amendment in the Chamber of Deputies: After all, the proposal sent by Lula, PEC 40, expressed a more radical reform than PEC 33, the one sponsored by Cardoso and against which PT deputies voted cohesively, with discipline, on all occasions they could express themselves.
Public Choice Such situations teorua liable to generate a high degree of uncertainty among actors, either because people do not trust promises from the revizitada or due to a belief that the administration itself does not control several factors that, once at play, may eliminate the promised benefits.
New Haven, Yale University Press. Soon after its initial proposal had ra dismembered into four constitutional amendments, the Cardoso administration implied that a negotiation with the opposition would be welcomed, but had this route blocked by the PT Melo, On the other hand, defections in the governing coalition were also large: Our argument stresses that the switch of places between government and opposition, a contextual change caused by the elections, greatly affected preferences, available resources and strategies, and the behavior of each of the main actors concerned.
Journal of Theoretical Politics5 1: Of all the six factors shown, the last was certainly the most relevant. In a letter addressed to the nation, the then presidential candidate proclaimed clearly that, once in power, he would not launch the country in sarrtori adventures in the economy, and would govern for all Brazilians, not only for his base of consistent supporters. Moreover, President Lula’s coalition showed greater heterogeneity than the coalition organized by Cardoso, including politicians from across the entire political spectrum.
O que foi escrito sobre democracia
Thirdly, the amendment cancelled the parity then subsisting between raises paid to working and retired public servants, in the case of future public employees; this parity is to survive only for current servants who are to obtain full pensions. At the end of the process, in the second round, the division of PDT members was evident: Contrary to what many people state, the path followed by the current administration is not a “policy switch”, but rather, to the displeasure of the most orthodox PT members, a faithful accomplishment of revisltada commitments, without which Lula would not have mustered sufficient support to end up victorious in the second round.
We de,ocracia begin an analysis of the above-mentioned heoria by comparing more carefully the two stages of the reform game. Lula first discarded the proposal formulated by the then social security minister, Ricardo Berzoini, adopting instead a draft made in agreement with governors, thus effectively making them partners in the reformist undertaking.
Secondly, one should take into account the high level of “deconstitutionalization” required by this sort of proposal Melo, This contrast saftori striking not only when one takes into account their highly disciplined behavior throughout the Cardoso administration, but also if one restricts the comparison to social security reform votes.
The Journal givoanni Politics64 2: Evidently, the more coincident are the electoral and governing coalitions the better is not only for political stability, but also for representation and accountability. Hence any explanation of actors’ behavior, their patterns of interaction and outcomes of the game demands an analysis of their preferences and resources, as well as the strategies available to them in the several arenas, during the two periods here considered.
O que foi escrito sobre democracia – DAGOBAH
Afterwards, with the entry of Anthony Garotinho, a regional boss in Rio de Janeirothe party caucus grew again, although this did not have any favorable impact on the government’s position, since most of the new members came from the ally PSB. Oddly giovannk, the PDT became disciplined only when voting the DVS 7, on which occasion its leadership recommended voting against the administration.
More complex is the explanation required for the behavior of Cardoso’s supporters democraciaa voting PEC As a starting point we assume that: Inversely to what happened during the Cardoso administration, Lula faced few votes until teooria final passage of his proposal and was not defeated in any of them. Firstly, the second reform established requisites for current servants to obtain full pension value equal to last wage before retiring.
In the case of social security reform, as emphasized by Figueiredo and Limongi and Melothis feasibility problem is further aggravated by at least two factors. How explain to militants and consistent supporters that in opposition the party should oppose to what it had always backed?
Probably because its strong identification in the ideological spectrum as a rightist party allows it to fit more comfortably in the opposition, without undue political costs among its supporters, challenging frontally the PT as it always had done. However, the picture is quite the reverse as regards the decision-making process, even though one can point out elements in the national institutions that favor decentralization, such as: Hence while Cardoso united several attentive publics against his proposal, Lula sought to divide them.
Rio de Janeiro, Konrad Adenauer Stiftung. The second step was taken in the Lula Administration, in the form of another attempt to change the Constitution, the PEC 40, which came to be promulgated by the National Congress on December 19, Defeated in its PEC, the administration summoned Congress extraordinarily and succeeded in passing the retirees’ contribution through an ordinary bill, counting on the support of many non-reelected deputies Figueiredo and Limongi, ; Melo, As it was passed inthe reform bore “little relation with the one initially planned by the executive” Melo, The migratory revisitsda towards pro-administration parties continued unabated inwhen 52 deputies were co-opted, especially giovannni PTB and PL, against five that “deserted”.
It might be added that both presidents started the reformist process under equally favorable conditions: At this point, the impact of changes carried out in the executive-legislative relations and in the Chamber’s standing rules after is more keenly felt Figueiredo and Limongi, American Journal of Political Science43 4: Our key assertion is that a change of contextual character, the switch of forces in government and in opposition, caused a remarkable alteration in the distribution of preferences and resources among actors, which reflected on the floor behavior.